How to Compare Car Repair Quotes From Different Shops

Two quotes for the same repair can differ by a lot, and the lower one is not always the better deal. The difference often comes from what is included. Comparing quotes fairly means making sure each one covers the same work.

Compare like for like

• Scope of work. Does each quote cover the same repairs, or is one leaving something out?

• Parts. OEM, aftermarket and remanufactured parts are priced differently and can perform differently.

• Labor. Compare the hours and the hourly rate, not just the total.

• Warranty. A longer warranty on parts and labor can be worth a slightly higher price.

• Timeline. A faster quote is only useful if the work is done properly.

How to get quotes you can actually compare

• Get two or three written, itemized estimates for the same repair.

• Describe the problem the same way to every shop, or let each one inspect the vehicle.

• Be cautious of a quote given over the phone without seeing the car, since it may change later.

• Ask each shop to explain any big differences between its quote and the others.

Related guides

New to reading estimates? See how to read a car repair estimate line by line, and review the questions to ask before you approve a repair. If you are in the Los Angeles area, Lux Auto Studio in Van Nuys can provide an itemized estimate for your vehicle.